How Colleges Are Using AI in Admissions Decisions

July 1, 2025

By: Syd Mania

Introduction

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is changing nearly every industry—and college admissions are no exception. What used to be a time-consuming, highly manual, and often subjective process is now evolving with the help of AI-driven tools. Universities are turning to machine learning algorithms, chatbots, and intelligent data systems to review, evaluate, and even interview applicants. These tools aren’t replacing human judgment, but they are transforming how decisions are made, making the process faster, more consistent, and—ideally—fairer.

So why is this trend gaining traction? Because today’s admissions teams are overwhelmed by thousands of applications. Each file contains essays, transcripts, recommendations, test scores, and more. AI makes it possible to manage all this data efficiently—identifying promising candidates, reducing bias, and helping schools build well-rounded, diverse student bodies. In this article, we’ll explore how colleges are using AI in the admissions process, what tools are being used, and what this means for students preparing to apply.


AI’s Growing Role in University Admissions

How AI Streamlines Application Review

AI is particularly well-suited to tasks that involve large amounts of data. In the case of admissions, that includes reading and sorting through thousands of application files. At the basic level, AI can scan transcripts and sort candidates based on GPA, test scores, and other quantitative criteria. This frees up admissions officers to focus on evaluating more subjective components like essays and recommendation letters.

Beyond filtering, machine learning algorithms can analyze historical data—looking at which admitted students thrived academically—and use that information to guide future admission decisions. This allows colleges to adjust their recruitment strategy based on trends in academic performance and workforce demand. For example, if a university wants to grow its computer science department, AI can help identify applicants who show promise in STEM-related skills or coursework.


Benefits of AI in the Admissions Process

Saving Time and Reducing Human Error

One of the biggest benefits of using AI in admissions is speed. The average admissions officer may only spend a few minutes on each application. AI tools can pre-screen materials and flag noteworthy applications, ensuring strong candidates don’t get overlooked in the rush.

This automation also helps minimize mistakes. Where human readers might miss something due to fatigue or unconscious bias, AI can maintain consistency across every review.


Identifying Key Traits in Applicants

AI doesn’t just look at numbers. Many tools are designed to identify soft skills and personal qualities that predict academic success—such as leadership, perseverance, and initiative. For instance, AI may scan essays or recommendation letters for certain keywords or themes that suggest a student has the qualities needed to thrive on campus.

This helps colleges move toward a more holistic review process, where personal growth and life experience are valued alongside academic achievement.


Supporting Diversity and Equity

AI can play a role in promoting fairness and diversity in admissions. When properly designed, these systems can avoid common biases related to race, gender, or socioeconomic background. Instead, they focus purely on academic potential and personal qualities, making room for students who might have otherwise been overlooked.

AI can even help schools target a more diverse group of applicants based on gaps in their current student population, supporting more inclusive recruitment strategies.


Enhancing the Student Experience with AI

Personalized Guidance Through Chatbots

For students, AI tools are also making the admissions experience smoother. Many schools now use AI-powered chatbots to answer questions 24/7. Whether it’s about application deadlines, scholarship opportunities, or program details, these bots are available anytime—reducing confusion and easing stress during the process.

Students can also receive tailored content based on their interests, like information about relevant majors or campus events, helping them stay engaged and informed throughout the application cycle.


Real-World AI Tools in Action

Reviewing Transcripts, Essays, and Recommendations

Today, AI tools are commonly used to scan high school transcripts for GPA thresholds, identify trends in test scores, and ensure that recommendation letters meet basic positivity criteria. In some cases, AI also checks personal essays for structure, originality, and coherence.

Some institutions are even using AI to screen for AI-generated writing, making sure applicants are presenting authentic work. Interview analysis tools are also emerging, with some universities using AI to transcribe, evaluate, or even conduct basic applicant interviews.


Case Study: RoBERTa at the University of Pennsylvania

Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania recently trained an AI model named RoBERTa to analyze more than 300,000 student essays. The model used a rubric designed by admissions officers to evaluate qualities like resilience and curiosity. The results showed strong alignment between the AI’s scoring and human evaluations, suggesting that AI could be a reliable support tool in reviewing large volumes of applications.


Addressing Ethical Concerns and Transparency

Avoiding the “Black Box” Problem

One of the major concerns surrounding AI in admissions is transparency. Many people worry that decisions are being made behind closed doors, with no clear explanation of how or why certain candidates are selected. This is known as the “black box” problem.

To avoid this, universities need to ensure their AI systems are explainable. That means sharing how the tools work, what criteria are being used, and how human reviewers are involved in the final decision. Transparency builds trust with students, families, and educators.


Ensuring Ethical Use of AI

AI systems must be built and trained by diverse teams to avoid reinforcing bias. Even though AI can help reduce subjectivity, it can still mirror the biases of its programmers or training data. Institutions need to carefully vet these systems and monitor how they impact admissions outcomes.

Ethical AI use means maintaining a balance—using automation to assist, not replace, human judgment. Admissions professionals should always have the final say, especially in cases where context or nuance is critical.

Also Read: Building a Standout Extracurricular Profile Post-COVID

Leave a Comment